[Mb-hair] Re: Re: REPLY TO VERY CONTROVERSIAL

[James Pappaconstantine]

Right on Dagmar.. I mirror your thoughts.. I am single and have tried these internet dating sites and many times, I read people's reply to my ad or in their profiles.. "Looking for God fearing man." What the hell is that? I am not going to fear something that I have doubts exsists and if one (or many) does exsist, then I am sure they are going to judge me on the good and bad I have done in life.. I am happy with my progress thus far and don't feel I will be turning into something different anytime soon. And if "GOD" is so loving.. why should I fear him?  It's crazy.. But.. I say as Lennon said.. "Whatever gets you through the night. " I don't care what people beleive in... I beleive in myself, and in Karma. And all I know is, that if I were. "GOD" the world would be in a different state of affairs. Funny that I should read this post today.. as I just came from my guitarist house where I put together a new song idea, dealing with simular subject matter and as an outro we are g
 oing to
 go into a verse of XTC's song, Dear God.
   
  Anyway.. Peace.. JIMMY P

"fotoblue at flash.net" <fotoblue at flash.net> wrote:
  well, consider this:
if there IS a God, and I myself have problems with this, 
given the current state of the world, the earth etc -
then he or she understands our reasons for doubting and not blindly
"believing".

SO: if you don't believe, you then are probably pleasantly surprised when
you die
to find out that he/she does exist, and I'm sure will be forgiven.

I certainly do NOT believe in the wrathful version that then casts
unbelievers into hell.
As we all know, HELL can be right here on earth. You don't have to wait for
it.
Some people even carry it inside themselves. ..

On this note, which probably will surprise a few fellow tribies,
I do wish you happy holidays, may it be Christmas, or Hanukkah, 
or whatever else you feel like celebrating.

Happy Third of Advent
P&L 
Dagmar




Original Message:
-----------------
From: Ian ialterman at nyc.rr.com
Date: Fri, 9 Dec 2005 11:45:03 -0500
To: dreamgrifter at yahoo.com
Subject: [Mb-hair] Re: Re: REPLY TO VERY CONTROVERSIAL


dreamgrifter:

In case you are unaware, what you have stated is the summation of what is 
called "Pascal's wager." Pascal put forward four premises. Simply stated 
they are:

"If I believe in God and there is no God, no harm is done. If I believe in 
God and there is a God, no harm is done, and good may come. If I do not 
believe in God and there is no God, no harm is done. If I do not believe
in 
God and there is a God, then harm may come. Thus, in three out of four 
cases, it is better (i.e., "safer") to believe in God than not to."

While this argument is certainly "logical" (which was Pascal's reason for 
stating it, given that he was a logician, among other things), attempting
to 
"hedge one's bets" by following it is, unfortunately, not enough.

Even my atheist older brother (a philosophy professor) was able to explain 
to my atheist younger brother (an amateur philosopher of sorts) why:
because 
if there is a God, He knows our HEARTS. Thus, simply "believing" in Him - 
i.e., stating such belief without "true, heartfelt faith" behind it - will 
not fool Him, and thus our "wager" ("hedging our bet") will ultimately fail.

Peace.


----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Michael Butler" 
To: "Ian Alterman" 
Sent: Friday, December 09, 2005 11:23 AM
Subject: FW: REPLY TO VERY CONTROVERSIAL


>
> ------ Forwarded Message
> From: "d st.b" 
> Date: Thu, 8 Dec 2005 22:01:11 -0800 (PST)
> To: Michael Butler 
> Subject: Re: REPLY TO VERY CONTROVERSIAL
>
> And on a much further and deeper note still....
> "I'd rather live my life believing in God, die and find out that I was
> wrong,
> Than live my life disbelieving in God, die and find that I was wrong."
>
> Michael Butler wrote:
> Ian has responded to Sam Harris's article "An Atheist Manifesto"
>
>

--------------------------------------------------------------------
mail2web - Check your email from the web at
http://mail2web.com/ .



_______________________________________________
Mb-hair mailing list
Mb-hair at islandlists.com
http://www.islandlists.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/mb-hair
  


			
---------------------------------
Yahoo! Shopping
 Find Great Deals on Holiday Gifts at Yahoo! Shopping 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://www.islandlists.com/pipermail/mb-hair/attachments/20051211/eb9f5394/attachment.htm